Idol Top 9

I hate going from Idol post to Idol post

with no post in between,

but it's just been that kind of week!

So here we go

American Idol Top 9

Lennon/McCartney week.

Aaron

Long and Winding Road

I agree with Ellen,

this was the long and winding song!

I didn't like it at all

and I thought he was shaky

through the whole thing.

Definitely an off night for Aaron.

Katie

Let it Be

This is my favorite performance to date

from Katie.

I did hear a lean towards country

in her vocals tonight

so I agree with Simon,

forget Cristina and Fergie

country is the way Katie should go!

Andrew

Can't Buy Me Love

Whenever I hear this song

it reminds me of the movie

"Can't Buy Me Love'

with pre-McDreamy Patrick Dempsey!

Loved that movie!

No matter what Andrew sings

I just like his tone so much.

He's very "relevant" as the judges would say.

It wasn't my favorite song on him,

but I think he has soooo much potential.

Mike

Eleanor Rigby

I actually liked this tonight.

It was good to see Mike take on

something dramatic and pull it off.

He's confident on stage

and always delivers a solid performance,

but I just can't get into him

for the long haul.

He shouldn't go yet, but he wont win.

Crystal

Come Together

Do we really need to keep going with this competition?

Let's just get it down to Lee and Crystal

and see what happens!

Crystal rocked it tonight!

Perfect song,

awesome performance,

slammin' vocals...

where do I buy my ticket?

Tim

All My Lovin'

Ok, much better than last week,

but still a little

cruise ship to me.

I'm glad he got a nod from Simon though,

it's hard to get beat up week after week

and keep that 1,000 kilowatt smile going.

Too bad it's not "smile idol".

Casey

Jealous guy

My absolute favorite from him!

I loved his look tonight.

The golden locks let loose

works for him

and so did this song!

Top three for sure!

Siobhan

Across The Universe

This song was sooo boring,

but it gave me a chance to try to

figure out what the girl was wearing!

It ws like she woke up and couldn't decide

between Madonna, southern belle,

biker chic or business woman,

so she just put it all on!

The outfit was definitely more interesting than the song.

I'm not sure what Siobhan is doing,

but she's losing momentum big time.

No scream though....

thanks girl!

Lee

Hey Jude

I love this song

and I loved it on him!

He's just such an honest

humble guy and I love his raspy voice.

I'd buy his CD today!

Weakest:

Siobahn

Tim

Aaron

Should go:

Tim